The plan was to spend on a replacement loan, which had previously granted the project central hospi

As can be at the disposal of the "News" correspondence, Vnesheconombank Chairman central hospital Vladimir Dmitriev unhappy state banks offered the role of lender of "last hand" in the project "RUSNANO" and the group "Renova" for the development of solar energy. The head of the corporation "RUSNANO" Anatoly Chubais, chairman of the board of directors and the group "Renova" Viktor Vekselbeg summer approached him with a letter in which he asked to give loan of 13.7 billion rubles.
The plan was to spend on a replacement loan, which had previously granted the project central hospital "RUSNANO" (to build a plant in Chuvashia to manufacture solar modules) plus accrued interest. However, in response to the request of Dmitry Medvedev to prepare central hospital proposals central hospital for such a deal harshly criticized the head of VEB project. Vladimir Dmitriev suspects that the bank offered to provide central hospital yield the release of "RUSNANO" of the project. In 2009, "RUSNANO" and the group of companies "Renova" Viktor Vekselberg invested in a joint project to build a plant for the production of Chuvashia solar modules based on the technology of "thin film" of Oerlicon (shareholder is "Renova"). The Project Company, LLC acted as "Hevel", 49% of the share capital of which belongs to the "RUSNANO", and 51% of the group "Renova". In accordance with the shares in OOO "Hevel" corporation contributed to the charter capital of the company 3700000000 rubles. Also, LLC "Hevel" has received a credit from the "RUSNANO" in the amount of 9800000000 rubles at 13% per annum for the construction of the plant in Cheboksary, scheduled for 2015 revenues in the amount of 5.8 billion rubles. Now Anatoly Chubais and Viktor Vekselberg, asked VEB to allocate a new loan to replace the previous 13.7 billion rubles at 5% per annum with a maturity of up to 2022 and Grace period up to the end of 2014. Vladimir Dmitriev, in a letter to the government apparatus harshly criticized the proposal, requiring the project company and the "RUSNANO" additional warranty. According to him, the project is very risky for Vnesheconombank. His weakest sides Dmitriev calls behind schedule by 20 months, and inability to compete for upcoming solar modules at the price and quality characteristics. As reported in a letter to Vladimir Dmitriev, purchased Oerlicon Solar technology is not innovative, purchased equipment modified production line of the first generation 1st generation ThinFab. At the beginning of 2012, the company Oerlicon Solar has announced the next generation of technology 2nd generation ThinFab with higher efficiency. In addition, the project is in a crisis of overproduction, currently the world's production capacity for solar modules at less than 50%, and this situation will continue in the medium term. At the same time, points, Vladimir Dmitriev, according to international analysts, there is a significant decline in prices central hospital for solar modules. The price of business products, established in the business plan is 1,34 / W and is overpriced central hospital compared to the current prices. For example, Chinese manufacturers are offering their units at the price of 0,6 / W, which is much below the cost of production "Hevel ( 0,98 / W). In the documentation provided by Vnesheconombank, there is agreement on the implementation of only 40% of the production plant. VEB has caused serious suspicions central hospital point agreement on a joint venture between "Renova" and "RUSNANO", according to which the corporation has an offer in 2016 to leave the project, taking the share capital of the company "Hevel" their share, and taking into account the fixed percent. If this happens, the budget of the project at the same time can be withdrawn 7 billion central hospital rubles. "One of the key initiators of the project is detached from its implementation, with the reward of the transaction for him remain in effect for the Preservation of the credit funds of the bank," says the head of Vnesheconombank. He was also surprised central hospital by the fact that Chubais and Vekselberg ask for money at 5% per annum, while the cost of raising resources by 2022 can not be below 11%. In the explanations that "RUSNANO" prepared for "Izvestia", states that the purpose of attracting refinancing project is lowering the interest rate on the loan and reduce costs. In "RUSNANO" central hospital also did not deny the possible release of the corporation from the project in 2016 as a state-owned corporation investment company "is considering various scenarios out of the projects that deliver the highest return," according to her answer. Representative of "Hevel" Anton Usachev in conversation with "Izvestia" has tried to protect the project. Oerlikon central hospital Solar technology is well known and widely used in solar energy, he said. The parameters of production costs and product quality, "Hevel" comparable not only to the European, but also with Chinese counterparts. Moreover, the company's business model includes not only the sale of units, but also projects central hospital the construction of solar power plants. According to him, the company intends to introduce in 2020 a system of four plants per year capacity of 25 MW by